Skip to content
Woman with curly hair on a beach styled with Payton jewelry from head to toe. Including our island pearls, payton clovers, and custom designs from our charm bar, pa and nj's original biggest and best.
Woman with curly hair on a beach styled with Payton jewelry from head to toe. Including our island pearls, payton clovers, and custom designs from our charm bar, pa and nj's original biggest and best.
Woman in a black dress adorned in a layer of Payton Jewelry Charm Bar Necklaces.
Woman sitting on a tennis court with a racket and balls styled in Payton nCharm jewelry and the Payton Clover Collection.
Model on a tennis court decked in Payton charm bar jewelry in layers from necklaces to bracelets, styles with our coin pearl hoops.
woman riding in stylish car with gold necklaces and gold charm bracelets

Shop by Collection

Shop All

Necklaces

Earrings

Bracelets

NEW LOCATION!

Locations & Hours

GRAND OPENING

We're Officially Open!

Four women on a beach, raising glasses together, with a scenic ocean view. Celebrate the special moments with Payton Jewelry at the original biggest and best charm bar in pa and nj.

Making Moments into Memories

Host A Party With Us! Get Sparked | Payton Unbreakable Bond

Versatile designs for every day

Shop sets

Crafted to last, designed to shine

About us

Loved by Our Community

Stories and reviews from those who wear and treasure these pieces.

My experience at Payton Jewelry services was great. The technician was super helpful and she did an amazing job on my necklace. I would definitely recommend this store for your next jewelry purchase.
Jessica G.
Jessica G.
Permanent Jewelry
I have had my coin necklace for over a year and I love wearing it everyday! It pairs with everything that I wear and just looks so unique!
Tabby
Tabby
LOVE. LOVE. LOVE.
Great experience at the Payton Jewelry store in Cape May! Both employees were extremely helpful and very knowledgeable on helping me pick the best positions for the charms and tightening the previous charms on there. They were super friendly and there were many Options of charms to choose from.
Suz H.
Suz H.
Great Experience!
This place has an amazing selection and on-site permanent jewelry! I came to the store twice on vacation and everyone was so friendly and I had no wait to get to get some permanent bracelets! Highly recommend!
Lauren E.
Lauren E.
Such a great experience! The worker was so sweet and made me feel super comfortable. My permanent jewelry turned out gorgeous—exactly what I wanted. Highly recommend!
Jacklyn S.
Love this unique experiential store! I have made charm necklaces here and got a permanent bracelet and both are amazing quality. So much fun and a great addition to a Cape May itinerary - especially for a girls trip!
Valery-Ann L.
Valery-Ann L.
My sister and I got permanent bracelets done by Alyza! We LOVE them! There was a big assortment of chains to choose from and charms. I chose a crystal heart connector charm and my sister got her angel numbers.
Tara P.
Tara P.
The girls were so helpful throughout the entire process of getting permanent bracelets, they were also very personable and kind. Would definitely come back for another!
Trinity E.
Trinity E.
Amazing for company parties!!!! Payton Jewelry came to our office holiday party as a gift, and it was a huge hit. So many chain options! I love my bracelet. I have my next appointment booked!!
Lura M.
Lura M.
Great little shop ~ Great concept I discovered this magical little shop because I was looking for a birthday gift for a 17 year old who loves the layering look of their merchandise. First time in ~ the sales woman was absolutely delightful! Very helpful! Very engaging and efficient. Everything you’d hope a sales person to be. About 45 minutes later ~ I departed with a beautiful necklace which my young birthday girl loved.
Mona
Mona